Human Rights Expert Advocates Abolishing Prostitution/Abortion Groups Upset

By | June 27, 2024

WASHINGTON, D.C. June 28 (C-Fam) Quite surprisingly, a UN human rights expert has issued a report advocating the abolition of prostitution. In addition, she calls for countries to abolish pornography and criminalize its possession and production.

Reem Alsalem, the special rapporteur on the causes and consequences of violence against women and girls, said that prostitution is a system of exploitation and abuse that “reduces women and girls to mere commodities” and “hinders their ability to achieve true equality.”

She explicitly refuses to use the term “sex work,” as it “wrongly depicts prostitution as an activity as worthy and dignified as any other work.”  Similarly, she referred to “victims” and “prostituted women and girls” rather than “sex workers” “in recognition of the scale of the harm experienced.”

The report endorses what has been called the “Nordic model,” where prostituted persons themselves are decriminalized, but buyers of sex acts and pimps face penalties. Critics will say that legalizing prostitution even in this way, only makes matters worse.

Noting the linkages between prostitution and pornography, Alsalem called on countries to work toward the abolition of pornography, and “and other forms of prostitution facilitated by digital platforms.”  Pending its abolition, Alsalem urged countries to use strict age verification and rigorous moderation for online platforms where pornography can be accessed.

She emphasized the importance of support services to help women and girls exit prostitution including “single-sex spaces.”

“Sexual rights” organizations, including the UN’s Women Deliver, criticized the report during the interactive dialogue with Alsalem where the report was launched.  The International Planned Parenthood Federation issued a scathing press release: “We denounce in the strongest terms the content of this report and the ideologically driven process that led to it,” they write. “There is no feminism without sex workers.”

Meanwhile, the report was hailed as “groundbreaking” and containing “astonishing clarity” by John Tuason of the U.S.-based National Center on Sexual Exploitation, who called on the UN system to adopt it.

Alsalem’s strong position against prostitution, as well as her criticism of some aspects of transgenderism as being harmful to women and girls, have been notable in recent years.  These issues have divided the feminist movement, and UN experts and agencies have been moving steadily toward normalizing “sex work” and promoting the most extreme aspects of gender ideology.

Earlier this year, the main UN human rights office opposed a resolution from the European Union calling on countries to criminalize pimping and purchasing sex acts.  Dr. Tlaleng Mofokeng, the special rapporteur on the right to health, has been an outspoken advocate for “sex work.”  The WHO, UNAIDS, UNFPA, and UNDP have adopted “sex work” terminology and campaigned for decriminalization, while the UN’s women’s agency has opted for a more cautious “neutral” position on the issue.  In this context, Alsalem’s report is a clear outlier.

Alsalem is not exactly a social conservative. She also presented the report of her recent visit to Poland, which was more closely aligned with the positions taken by other UN human rights experts and committees. She criticized restrictions on abortion and called for “strict regulation of the use of the conscientious objection.”  She called for “comprehensive sexual education in all schools” and the adoption of “a law that spells out a procedure for legal gender recognition” as well as bans on so-called “conversion therapies.”

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter